A close-up of baked macaroni and cheese with the text Thanksgiving Mac & Cheese overlaid.

Southern Mac and Cheese: Creamy Four Cheese Recipe

Author

  • A woman with dark hair in a ponytail smiles at the camera, wearing a black shirt and a blue apron, standing indoors with neutral-colored curtains and a ceiling fan in the background.

    Blue Collar Wife 💍 TX Cookin 👩🏻‍🍳 Tex Mex 🌮 Budget Meals 🙏🏼 Cast Iron Cookin 🍳 TX BBQ 🍖 Easy Recipes

Blue Collar Chef

Want to see more of my creations?

Tell Google you want to see more of my creations in your search results.

Southern Mac and Cheese: Creamy Four Cheese Recipe This baked macaroni and cheese combines al dente pasta noodles with a four-cheese mixture made from sharp cheddar, low-skim mozzarella, Colby Jack, and Monterey Jack. Heavy whipping cream is added gradually as the cheese melts, giving you control over the thickness before the pasta goes into the casserole dish.

Watch How to Make It

The finished casserole bakes at 375 until the top is bubbly. Bread crumbs are optional, but when used, they are added after the first bake and returned to the oven briefly.

Why You'll Love This Recipe

The cheese mixture brings together four different shredded cheeses in one pot before it is added to the pasta. Sharp cheddar, low-skim mozzarella, Colby Jack, and Monterey Jack are all shredded before cooking so they are ready to add once the butter is in the pot.

Smoked paprika, garlic powder, onion powder, salt, and pepper season the cheese mixture. The seasonings are included to taste, allowing them to be worked into the melted cheese and cream before the casserole is assembled.

The heavy whipping cream is added slowly once the cheese begins to melt. The recipe starts with 4 to 5 ounces, with the option to add more gradually if you want a thinner consistency.

Ingredients You'll Need

You will need butter; 8 ounces each of sharp cheddar, low-skim mozzarella, Colby Jack, and Monterey Jack cheese; heavy whipping cream; and pasta noodles. The cheese should all be shredded before it is added to the pot.

Season the cheese mixture with smoked paprika, garlic powder, onion powder, salt, and pepper to taste. Bread crumbs are optional for the final topping.

The preparation uses a pot for melting the butter, cheese, and cream, along with a 9×13 casserole dish for combining the noodles and cheese before baking. Have the cheeses shredded before beginning the cheese mixture so they can be added together.

Cooking

Melt the butter in a pot over medium-low heat. Add the shredded cheeses, then season with smoked paprika, garlic powder, onion powder, salt, and pepper to taste.

Once the cheese begins to melt, slowly add the heavy whipping cream. Begin with the listed 4 to 5 ounces, keeping the addition gradual as the cheese and cream come together.

Preparation

Pour the al dente pasta noodles into a 9×13 casserole dish. The pasta goes into the dish before the cheese mixture, leaving room to add the melted cheese slowly over the noodles.

If you want the cheese mixture to be thinner, slowly add more heavy whipping cream while it is in the pot. Make this consistency adjustment before combining the cheese with the pasta in the casserole dish.

Cooking

Slowly add the melted cheese mixture over the pasta noodles in the 9×13 casserole dish. Gently combine the noodles and cheese, taking care to keep the mixing gradual as directed.

Bake the casserole at 375 until the top is bubbly. The bubbling top is the stated point for the initial bake.

If using bread crumbs, add them after the casserole has baked until bubbly. Gently press the bread crumbs into the casserole, then place it back in the oven for about 3 to 5 minutes.

Pro-tip: Add the heavy whipping cream slowly once the cheese starts melting. This is the point where the recipe allows you to keep the mixture thick or gradually add more cream for a thinner consistency.

How To Make It

Boil your pasta noodles until they are al dente. Add butter to a pot on medium low, Shred all of your cheese add it to your pot. Once cheese begins to melt, add in the heavy whipping cream slowly. My family likes their consistency thick, if you want thinner slowly add more heavy whipping cream, until it’s to the consistency you like. Pour your pasta noodles in a 9×13 casserole dish, then slowly add the melted cheese to the top, slowly combine gently.

Bake at 375 until the top is bubbly. I like to at times top with bread crumbs, then gently press them into the casserole, place back in the oven for about 3-5 minutes.

Serving & Variations

Serve the macaroni and cheese once it has baked until bubbly, or complete the optional bread crumb finish first. The bread crumbs are not part of the initial bake; they are added afterward and pressed gently into the casserole before the brief return to the oven.

The main adjustment in this recipe is the consistency of the cheese mixture. Starting with 4 to 5 ounces of heavy whipping cream and adding more only as needed keeps that adjustment within the melting stage, before the pasta and cheese are gently combined.

A plate of food containing macaroni and cheese, baked beans with small sausages, sliced ham, and yams, with Family Sunday Dinner text overlaid.

Frequently Asked Questions

What cheeses are used in Southern Mac and Cheese?

The recipe uses sharp cheddar, low skim mozzarella, Colby Jack, and Monterey Jack cheese.

How should I cook the pasta noodles?

Boil the pasta noodles until they are al dente.

Can I make the cheese sauce thinner?

Yes. If you want a thinner consistency, slowly add more heavy whipping cream until it reaches the consistency you like.

What size casserole dish should I use?

Pour the pasta noodles into a 9x13 casserole dish.

Can I add bread crumbs on top?

Yes. You can top the mac and cheese with bread crumbs, gently press them into the casserole, and place it back in the oven for about 3-5 minutes.

Wrapping Up

This four-cheese macaroni and cheese moves from al dente noodles to a gently combined casserole with a bubbly baked top. Use the optional bread crumb step for a short final bake after the casserole is already finished baking.

Recipe created by Blue Collar Chef for Trust Me Try It.

A close-up of baked macaroni and cheese with the text Thanksgiving Mac & Cheese overlaid.

Southern Mac and Cheese: Creamy Four Cheese Recipe

Print Pin Rate
Prep Time: 20 minutes
Cook Time: 45 minutes
Total Time: 1 hour 5 minutes
Servings: 6

Ingredients

  • 3 tb;s butter,
  • 8 oz Sharp cheddar, 8oz
  • Low skim mozzarella, 8oz
  • Colby Jack, 8oz
  • Monterey Jack cheese
  • 4-5 oz heavy whipping cream. Season with smoked paprika, garlic powder
  • salt and pepper to taste,
  • onion powder,
  • 16 oz pasta noodles.
  • Top with bread crumbs if you wish!

Instructions

  • Boil your pasta noodles until they are al dente. Add butter to a pot on medium low, Shred all of your cheese add it to your pot. Once cheese begins to melt, add in the heavy whipping cream slowly.
  • My family likes their consistency thick, if you want thinner slowly add more heavy whipping cream, until it’s to the consistency you like. Pour your pasta noodles in a 9×13 casserole dish, then slowly add the melted cheese to the top, slowly combine gently.
  • Bake at 375 until the top is bubbly. I like to at times top with bread crumbs, then gently press them into the casserole, place back in the oven for about 3-5 minutes.

Related Recipes

One Comment

  1. Brad Mobley says:

    5 stars
    This looks like the perfect Mac and Cheese recipe!!! Thank you for sharing this recipe!!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating